Iliman Ndiaye (City back on the menu)

[UnsyisaRhino]

Is Brighton the club we aspire to be like?

In terms of transfer policy? I'd say so yeah.

[Cereal Killer]

into the conference qualifying rounds after a late run in the PL last season?

what CL football?

You know, that Champions League thing they played in twice in the last three seasons

Or you thinking we should aspire to be Arsenal? Or City? Or the shite?

[StirlingBlue]

??

You're moving the goalposts.

You said selling your best players means that other young players won't sign for us, it was rightly pointed out that the likes of Brighton do that and young players still sign for them so you changed the it to be about "Well we don't want to be like Brighton".

Player trading and giving young players a platform to shine and get their big move is our only way to improve from where we are today - look at the likes of Bournemouth, Brighton, Brentford etc who have way less resources than us but outdo us regularly. If we can follow a similar model but as a bigger club with more resources that's our route back to the european places

[CorkyOnTour]

So you don't want us keeping our best players and adding to them?

Ok. I think differently.

[CorkyOnTour]

You're moving the goalposts.

You said selling your best players means that other young players won't sign for us, it was rightly pointed out that the likes of Brighton do that and young players still sign for them so you changed the it to be about "Well we don't want to be like Brighton".

Player trading and giving young players a platform to shine and get their big move is our only way to improve from where we are today - look at the likes of Bournemouth, Brighton, Brentford etc who have way less resources than us but outdo us regularly. If we can follow a similar model but as a bigger club with more resources that's our route back to the european places

There's no goal posts being moved...you used Brighton as the example and I asked if wanted us to aspire to be like Brighton.

[UnsyisaRhino]

So you don't want us keeping our best players and adding to them?

Ok. I think differently.

It's not the simple.

We're in a position where to compete, we have to find talent at lower prices keep them for as long as we can, and sell them when we can get enough money to fuel multiple purchases that help us to continue moving forward. We can put a 'fuck off' price to keep people for longer and to maximise the benefits but at some point we will need to sell. Either they'll run out their contract or force a move some other way.

Eventually we'll reach a point where we can probably hang on to them for a bit longer, especially if we start qualifying for europe or reaching the odd final. Without sales of big players, we won't be able to compete with the clubs above us.

[StirlingBlue]

There's no goal posts being moved...you used Brighton as the example and I asked if wanted us to aspire to be like Brighton.

In terms of transfer policy yes I absolutely do - what do you want us to do? More Moshiri-esque mega deals? Hold onto players to where they have no resale value?

[Cereal Killer]

So you don't want us keeping our best players and adding to them?

Ok. I think differently.

You need to sell to buy more though

Sell one star player for top dollar, buy 2/3 high potential players, sell another the next year, buy another 2/3

Then you can try and build a great team

[CorkyOnTour]

You know, that Champions League thing they played in twice in the last three seasons

Or you thinking we should aspire to be Arsenal? Or City? Or the shite?

Brighton in the champions league?
what?

[CorkyOnTour]

You need to sell to buy more though

Sell one star player for top dollar, buy 2/3 high potential players, sell another the next year, buy another 2/3

Then you can try and build a great team

Do Man Utd, Man City, Liverpool, Arsenal, Chelsea, Spurs etc sell their best players to buy more?

[CorkyOnTour]

In terms of transfer policy yes I absolutely do - what do you want us to do? More Moshiri-esque mega deals? Hold onto players to where they have no resale value?

I am not talking about transfer policy..I am talking about ambition and intent

[Bluebridge]

Do Man Utd, Man City, Liverpool, Arsenal, Chelsea, Spurs etc sell their best players to buy more?

Yes they do/did.

[CorkyOnTour]

Which top players have they got rid of this summer?

[MayorFarnham]

Villa and Newcastle have been on an upward trajectory for about five years now, including CL qualification, and they still can't hold on to their better players.
I doubt we can do much about it even if we wanted to keep certain players.

[CorkyOnTour]

Yes and look at what happens when they sell their best players...
Look at Aston Villa and Newcastle this season.

Its not a long-term sustainable model