Dwight McNeil

This is the new NSNO Everton forum to discuss the Mighty Blues
Toddacelli
Posts: 2623
Karma: 2742

Re: Dwight McNeil

Post

Players like DMc are why we finished where we did.

Chuck McNeil, Keane, Tarkowski, Mykolenko, Patterson and Barry in a pile, chuck a match on it and walk away.

Actually, looking at how many of them are defenders is pretty fucking telling.
brap2
Posts: 5636
Karma: 5571

Re: Dwight McNeil

Post

Wrexham
Bumble
Posts: 825
Karma: 505

Re: Dwight McNeil

Post

The fact his move fell through and he played so many minutes after January shows the manager gives zero thoughts about the future.

Should have been nowhere near the first team after that.
AjaxAndy
Posts: 6793
Karma: 3339

Re: Dwight McNeil

Post

Bumble wrote: Wed May 20, 2026 8:39 am The fact his move fell through and he played so many minutes after January shows the manager gives zero thoughts about the future.

Should have been nowhere near the first team after that.
Or he was attempting to retain his value so we'd get £20m in the summer possibly.

If he felt there wasn't any benefit to playing Dibling over him in terms of impact on the pitch (obviously his development would be a benefit), then I could understand him continuing to play him.

What I can't really understand is the dropping him and playing Rohl there instead, even if he did really well in very specific circumstances against City.
Trowel
User avatar
Posts: 2545
Karma: 3336

Re: Dwight McNeil

Post

bigmanbob
Posts: 1218
Karma: 433

Re: Dwight McNeil

Post

Jesus Summerville for MCNeill is some come down
Granite
Posts: 1030
Karma: 494

Re: Dwight McNeil

Post

Yep, move on
AjaxAndy
Posts: 6793
Karma: 3339

Re: Dwight McNeil

Post

bigmanbob wrote: Tue Jun 23, 2026 1:06 pm Jesus Summerville for MCNeill is some come down
Imagine when they realise they've swapped Bowen for McNeil! 🤣
kramer
Posts: 2183
Karma: 2500

Re: Dwight McNeil

Post

Yikes. Nobody with ambition of coming back for an extended stay should be targeting him.

I’ve enjoyed him at times, his left foot is that good and he used to have an engine to prop it up, but the declining athleticism and work rate and non-existent right foot means a club that can get promoted but has trouble sticking truly his level.

Think he makes more sense for a Boro, Millwall, or one of the teams that just missed the playoff than West Ham.
Bluebridge
Posts: 2485
Karma: 1396

Re: Dwight McNeil

Post

kramer wrote: Wed Jun 24, 2026 1:06 am Yikes. Nobody with ambition of coming back for an extended stay should be targeting him.

I’ve enjoyed him at times, his left foot is that good and he used to have an engine to prop it up, but the declining athleticism and work rate and non-existent right foot means a club that can get promoted but has trouble sticking truly his level.

Think he makes more sense for a Boro, Millwall, or one of the teams that just missed the playoff than West Ham.
Shush, West Ham people might be lurking 👀
Sirblue57
Posts: 387
Location: Torrevieja
Karma: 82

Re: Dwight McNeil

Post

Juanito wrote: Mon Jul 14, 2025 11:21 am Wow! I actually googled, he scored 320 with his left foot, 6 with his right foot, 26 with his head and one with his left hand!
:lol:
Blueomar
User avatar
Posts: 2875
Location: California Love
Karma: 1141

Re: Dwight McNeil

Post

bigmanbob wrote: Tue Jun 23, 2026 1:06 pm Jesus Summerville for MCNeill is some come down
Haven't the hammers supporters suffered enough?
Toddacelli
Posts: 2623
Karma: 2742

Re: Dwight McNeil

Post

Blueomar wrote: Wed Jun 24, 2026 7:12 pm Haven't the hammers supporters suffered enough?
Absolutely not.
Trowel
User avatar
Posts: 2545
Karma: 3336

Re: Dwight McNeil

Post

When Ex retweets his old stuff like this, it's usually because something is about to happen... 🤞 🤞 🤞

kramer
Posts: 2183
Karma: 2500

Re: Dwight McNeil

Post

I do wish him the best however this shakes out.

I liked watching him quite a bit when we first signed him despite the obvious limitations. But there’s been a noticeable decline in his work rate and how often he gets on the ball which makes him wide Sigurdsson (and with only one good foot).

Hope he finds joy again scoring bangers for a promotion candidate.
Post Reply Previous topicNext topic