Summer Transfer Window 2026

The NSNO Everton Forum – the place for Everton fans to discuss Everton FC, matchday, team news, transfer rumours, players, managers and everything happening at Bramley Moore Dock
Posts: 6108
Joined: Wed Nov 22, 2023 11:39 pm
Karma: 6295

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2026

Post

Matt1878 wrote: Wed Sep 02, 2026 5:07 pm Average age of squad

Brighton 24.6
Everton 25.3
Bournemouth 25.5
Brentford 25.8

https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/premier ... bewerb/GB1

I'd say we're trying to follow a similar model, our older players (Picks/Tarks/Keane) are just old because they have been around for ages. We do have a decent young talent pool in the team and we've sold our best player for a sizeable profit.

Is our model that different? Or are we just more innept at getting the deals done along with a complete disconnect with the manager's approach in terms of backing youth... as when we do sign them (Dibling, Aznou... possibly George now Grealish is back) they're not what he wants.
Yeah, we are very very different.

One random example - our options at ST on deadline day were

1. Keeping Beto
2. Signing Balogun
3. Loaning Zirkzee
4. Signing Tammy

One position, four very different options. Is he going to be a back up? Is he going to be the main man? Is he here for 6 months, is he here for 4 years, is he good in the air, good on the break, good with his feet but barely gets past a jog, does he score goals, what level has he scored goals, does he get assists, what kinds of teams has he played in and what role did he play….

One position, a million variables and we are picking from 4 different plates.

Brentford have set profiles agreed at all levels. They are ONLY interested in players who fit what they have all agreed is right for each position and need. Their strikers are good at x y z. They have wide forwards who are good at x y z. When they spend it is on players who look like x y z. When they sign short term it is on players who look like x y z to do a b c jobs.

Lose toney, your talismanic line stretching cf who is good with his feet and a physical battle to deal with? Sign Thiago. Lose mbuemo your left footed right winger* known for his blistering pace and threat when cutting inside? Sign Dango.

Then Brighton tbh are another level again, with players signing for them in this window you won’t see for another 2 years.

I’m sure there’s exceptions at these clubs and transfers that haven’t worked and Aaron hickey doesn’t look exactly like their other rb etc etc but the fact is…both of these clubs were mid table championship sides in the last 10-15 years.

They’ve implemented strategies and structures that go beyond manager, head coach, DOF, CEO, one window, two window. If their manager leaves they don’t go back to the drawing board and ask who are we, they say who suits who we are? If apple’s CEO leaves they don’t start selling garden tools.

Could you confidently say who we are? Could you confidently say who decides that? When was the last time we did know, and what happens in 6 months time when the manager is sacked, or in two weeks time when the ceo is sacked…who are we then?

It’s not enough to spend 40m on dibbling and have your manager treat him like an U21 graduate, he might bring your average age profile down but the plan isn’t joined together top to bottom and tbh most of the time doesn’t look like there is a plan beyond listen to whoever won this seasons boardroom battle.
Posts: 1595
Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2023 7:23 am
Karma: 1182

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2026

Post

brap2 wrote: Wed Sep 02, 2026 8:04 pm Yeah, we are very very different.

One random example - our options at ST on deadline day were

1. Keeping Beto
2. Signing Balogun
3. Loaning Zirkzee
4. Signing Tammy

One position, four very different options. Is he going to be a back up? Is he going to be the main man? Is he here for 6 months, is he here for 4 years, is he good in the air, good on the break, good with his feet but barely gets past a jog, does he score goals, what level has he scored goals, does he get assists, what kinds of teams has he played in and what role did he play….

One position, a million variables and we are picking from 4 different plates.

Brentford have set profiles agreed at all levels. They are ONLY interested in players who fit what they have all agreed is right for each position and need. Their strikers are good at x y z. They have wide forwards who are good at x y z. When they spend it is on players who look like x y z. When they sign short term it is on players who look like x y z to do a b c jobs.

Lose toney, your talismanic line stretching cf who is good with his feet and a physical battle to deal with? Sign Thiago. Lose mbuemo your left footed right winger* known for his blistering pace and threat when cutting inside? Sign Dango.

Then Brighton tbh are another level again, with players signing for them in this window you won’t see for another 2 years.

I’m sure there’s exceptions at these clubs and transfers that haven’t worked and Aaron hickey doesn’t look exactly like their other rb etc etc but the fact is…both of these clubs were mid table championship sides in the last 10-15 years.

They’ve implemented strategies and structures that go beyond manager, head coach, DOF, CEO, one window, two window. If their manager leaves they don’t go back to the drawing board and ask who are we, they say who suits who we are? If apple’s CEO leaves they don’t start selling garden tools.

Could you confidently say who we are? Could you confidently say who decides that? When was the last time we did know, and what happens in 6 months time when the manager is sacked, or in two weeks time when the ceo is sacked…who are we then?

It’s not enough to spend 40m on dibbling and have your manager treat him like an U21 graduate, he might bring your average age profile down but the plan isn’t joined together top to bottom and tbh most of the time doesn’t look like there is a plan beyond listen to whoever won this seasons boardroom battle.
Nailed it.

When is the last time that the club really knew what it wanted to be and that had all parties pulling in the same direction.

I maintain that it’s very difficult to know what we are trying to achieve. Some of that isn’t our fault (ridiculous transfer values etc). But you have to play the cards you are dealt.

We don’t have particularly good cards and it also appears that we are a shitty card player.
Posts: 2967
Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 5:24 pm
Karma: 3830

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2026

Post

Gary1878 wrote: Wed Sep 02, 2026 8:36 pm Nailed it.

When is the last time that the club really knew what it wanted to be and that had all parties pulling in the same direction.

I maintain that it’s very difficult to know what we are trying to achieve. Some of that isn’t our fault (ridiculous transfer values etc). But you have to play the cards you are dealt.

We don’t have particularly good cards and it also appears that we are a shitty card player.
"If you can't spot the sucker in your first half hour at the table, then you are the sucker."
Posts: 7675
Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 11:28 am
Karma: 3889

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2026

Post

brap2 wrote: Wed Sep 02, 2026 8:04 pm Yeah, we are very very different.

One random example - our options at ST on deadline day were

1. Keeping Beto
2. Signing Balogun
3. Loaning Zirkzee
4. Signing Tammy

One position, four very different options. Is he going to be a back up? Is he going to be the main man? Is he here for 6 months, is he here for 4 years, is he good in the air, good on the break, good with his feet but barely gets past a jog, does he score goals, what level has he scored goals, does he get assists, what kinds of teams has he played in and what role did he play….

One position, a million variables and we are picking from 4 different plates.

Brentford have set profiles agreed at all levels. They are ONLY interested in players who fit what they have all agreed is right for each position and need. Their strikers are good at x y z. They have wide forwards who are good at x y z. When they spend it is on players who look like x y z. When they sign short term it is on players who look like x y z to do a b c jobs.

Lose toney, your talismanic line stretching cf who is good with his feet and a physical battle to deal with? Sign Thiago. Lose mbuemo your left footed right winger* known for his blistering pace and threat when cutting inside? Sign Dango.

Then Brighton tbh are another level again, with players signing for them in this window you won’t see for another 2 years.

I’m sure there’s exceptions at these clubs and transfers that haven’t worked and Aaron hickey doesn’t look exactly like their other rb etc etc but the fact is…both of these clubs were mid table championship sides in the last 10-15 years.

They’ve implemented strategies and structures that go beyond manager, head coach, DOF, CEO, one window, two window. If their manager leaves they don’t go back to the drawing board and ask who are we, they say who suits who we are? If apple’s CEO leaves they don’t start selling garden tools.

Could you confidently say who we are? Could you confidently say who decides that? When was the last time we did know, and what happens in 6 months time when the manager is sacked, or in two weeks time when the ceo is sacked…who are we then?

It’s not enough to spend 40m on dibbling and have your manager treat him like an U21 graduate, he might bring your average age profile down but the plan isn’t joined together top to bottom and tbh most of the time doesn’t look like there is a plan beyond listen to whoever won this seasons boardroom battle.
An excellent post 🙌
Posts: 771
Joined: Sat Oct 28, 2023 6:38 am
Karma: 326

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2026

Post

Phil McNulty as usual very good at exposing the issues at Everton for everyone to read

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/ar ... 861n79kepo
Posts: 4510
Joined: Fri Oct 27, 2023 7:11 am
Karma: 1692

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2026

Post

Give me six months of Raphael Guerreiro playing behind Grealish
Posts: 9590
Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 4:42 pm
Karma: 10032

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2026

Post

https://www.dailymail.com/sport/footbal ... lapse.html

Anyone get behind the paywall for this?
Posts: 5288
Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 7:36 pm
Karma: 2102

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2026

Post

"Everton officials are not considering dipping into the free market pool" apparently Dominic King
Posts: 1021
Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2024 8:57 pm
Karma: 276

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2026

Post

blueToffee wrote: Wed Sep 02, 2026 9:55 pm "Everton officials are not considering dipping into the free market pool" apparently Dominic King
Why on earth would anyone expect this to happen. Surely bulking up the squad with a few average players is better than nothing.
Posts: 420
Joined: Wed Jan 08, 2025 9:05 am
Karma: 191

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2026

Post

brap2 wrote: Wed Sep 02, 2026 8:04 pm Yeah, we are very very different.

One random example - our options at ST on deadline day were

1. Keeping Beto
2. Signing Balogun
3. Loaning Zirkzee
4. Signing Tammy

One position, four very different options. Is he going to be a back up? Is he going to be the main man? Is he here for 6 months, is he here for 4 years, is he good in the air, good on the break, good with his feet but barely gets past a jog, does he score goals, what level has he scored goals, does he get assists, what kinds of teams has he played in and what role did he play….

One position, a million variables and we are picking from 4 different plates.

Brentford have set profiles agreed at all levels. They are ONLY interested in players who fit what they have all agreed is right for each position and need. Their strikers are good at x y z. They have wide forwards who are good at x y z. When they spend it is on players who look like x y z. When they sign short term it is on players who look like x y z to do a b c jobs.

Lose toney, your talismanic line stretching cf who is good with his feet and a physical battle to deal with? Sign Thiago. Lose mbuemo your left footed right winger* known for his blistering pace and threat when cutting inside? Sign Dango.

Then Brighton tbh are another level again, with players signing for them in this window you won’t see for another 2 years.

I’m sure there’s exceptions at these clubs and transfers that haven’t worked and Aaron hickey doesn’t look exactly like their other rb etc etc but the fact is…both of these clubs were mid table championship sides in the last 10-15 years.

They’ve implemented strategies and structures that go beyond manager, head coach, DOF, CEO, one window, two window. If their manager leaves they don’t go back to the drawing board and ask who are we, they say who suits who we are? If apple’s CEO leaves they don’t start selling garden tools.

Could you confidently say who we are? Could you confidently say who decides that? When was the last time we did know, and what happens in 6 months time when the manager is sacked, or in two weeks time when the ceo is sacked…who are we then?

It’s not enough to spend 40m on dibbling and have your manager treat him like an U21 graduate, he might bring your average age profile down but the plan isn’t joined together top to bottom and tbh most of the time doesn’t look like there is a plan beyond listen to whoever won this seasons boardroom battle.
Spot on, mate!

Just - add one more important thing - mentality.

De Zerbi said after the match against Newcastle that you can't buy mentality and he got criticized by a Norwegian expert saying - that is exactly what you buy - its your freakin job to buy players with good mentality. This expert has worked a lot as a scout and he then said that Brightons scout reports - half of it is about the players personality, character and mentality.

You have no clue about the players mentality if you're signing players just to put out fires like our club is doing.
Posts: 1894
Joined: Sun Oct 29, 2023 3:37 am
Karma: 1083

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2026

Post

“We’ll go with what we’ve got” according to this in the Telegraph:

Everton not looking at free agents despite failure to land Balogun

David Moyes’s team looks worryingly short up front after deadline-day farce. Plus, we look at the most enticing free agents on the market
Everton are not ready to take the emergency step of exploring the free-agent market after their farcical finish to the transfer window.
The Merseyside club have faced a furious backlash from supporters over a series of failings that included Folarin Balogun walking out on a deal that would have seen him move to Everton from AS Monaco, even though he had earlier failed a medical.
It was a chaotic end to the summer, with a claim Chelsea failed with £65m bid to sign James Garner after Everton had already brought in £100m in sales on deadline day through Iliman Ndiaye, Tim Iroegbunam, Nathan Patterson and Beto. Everton refute there was direct contact from Chelsea.


What is impossible to deny, however, is the fact David Moyes’s squad is short in attack. Balogun left officials gobsmacked as both he and Monaco had signed a deal sheet at 11pm that was submitted to the Premier League to give Everton an extra two hours to work on concluding business.
Monaco had agreed to a significant restructuring of an initial £39m transfer – and did not contest Everton’s medical findings – but just after 12am, the United States international made it clear he had had a change of heart and wanted to go back to Monaco.
Having sold Beto, Everton are now left with just Thierno Barry as their sole recognised striker but officials are not considering dipping into a pool yet in which players such as Jamie Vardy, Anthony Martial, Mauro Icardi and Karim Benzema are all immediately available.

They insist there are options within: Brennan Johnson, who moved to Hill Dickinson Stadium from Crystal Palace in a straight swap with Dwight McNeil, has played through the middle in his career; there also may be opportunities, in time, for the young exciting forward Braiden Graham.
Everton had looked at striking deals for Manchester United’s Joshua Zirkzee and Tammy Abraham of Aston Villa as the Balogun deal floundered, and it is claimed that is what swayed the former Arsenal academy graduate to consider his options.

Everton’s transfer window business
Incoming players
Player: Hayden Hackney | Club: Middlesbrough | Value: £24m
Player: Tyrique George | Club: Chelsea | Value: £24m
Player: Merlin Rohl | Club: Freiburg | Value: £19m
Player: Brennan Johnson | Club: Crystal Palace | Value: Swap
Player: Christian Norgaard | Club: Arsenal | Value: £7m
Player: Jack Grealish | Club: Man City | Value: Loan
Player: Ainsley Maitland-Niles | Club: Lyon | Value: £3m
Total: £77m


Outgoing players
Player: Dwight McNeil | Club: Crystal Palace | Outcome: Swap
Player: Adam Aznou | Club: Malaga | Outcome: Loan
Player: Nathan Patterson | Club: Torino | Outcome: £800,000
Player: Iliman Ndiaye | Club: Man City | Outcome: £65m
Player: Beto | Club: Fiorentina | Outcome: £15.4m
Player: Tim Iroegbunam | Club: Hull City | Outcome: £22m
Player: Idrissa Gueye | Club: Al-Diriyah | Outcome: Free
Player: Tyler Onyango | Club: Sheffield Wednesday | Outcome: Free
Total: £103.2m

Thiago Scuro, Monaco’s sporting director, said: “Balogun was in Liverpool undergoing his medical. Everything was going pretty well. Around 7pm, we were contacted by Everton, raising questions about Balogun’s medical, which, for our medical staff, as well as for the player’s personal medical staff, made no sense at all.
“Five minutes to close the transfer window there, for us to finish all the paperwork between Monaco and Everton and ‘Balo’. I signed the contract. Everton signed the contract. At the last moment, the player decided not to sign.
“And basically, Balogun’s allegation is that I’m not feeling well because of the way the club treated me. I’m not feeling well because Everton’s medical department raised doubts about my future or my health. I have nothing [no health problem], so I’m not comfortable signing a long contract here.”

Angus Kinnear, Everton’s chief executive, is among the officials who have come under fire from fans, and one group, called the 1878s, who are responsible for decorating the stadium with tifos and banners, captured the disgruntled mood when posting a statement on social media.
It said: “If we were able to get a load of flags in the ground to show our feelings of discontent, disappointment and anger over this whole situation, believe us, we would, but this is something that simply wouldn’t be allowed.
“We stated on Sunday that we do not feel that our fanbase’s ambitions and the club’s ambitions align right now – what happened yesterday has proved that even more. As a group we will still be standing down for the foreseeable future.”
Posts: 41
Joined: Sat Aug 01, 2026 7:36 am
Karma: 37

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2026

Post

Posts: 744
Joined: Sat Nov 18, 2023 2:00 am
Karma: 407

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2026

Post

Thank you for posting this.
I wasn’t aware of redundancies in the club over the Summer. Does anyone know what reason was given and how many people lost their jobs?
Posts: 1815
Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2023 5:09 pm
Karma: 1633

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2026

Post

I think too much emphasis is being put on a solitary transfer falling through. It's a bit shitty, but these things happen.

The entire window was a failure. Those saying we should wait till the window closes can now see why people were getting angry a month ago.

And fuck City and Ndiaye a bit.
In future, I'd be telling all of our players and agents that the transfer window closes on the 23rd of August if they're a starter.
Posts: 160
Joined: Wed Nov 01, 2023 8:30 am
Karma: 65

Re: Summer Transfer Window 2026

Post

brap2 wrote: Wed Sep 02, 2026 8:04 pm Yeah, we are very very different.

One random example - our options at ST on deadline day were

1. Keeping Beto
2. Signing Balogun
3. Loaning Zirkzee
4. Signing Tammy

One position, four very different options. Is he going to be a back up? Is he going to be the main man? Is he here for 6 months, is he here for 4 years, is he good in the air, good on the break, good with his feet but barely gets past a jog, does he score goals, what level has he scored goals, does he get assists, what kinds of teams has he played in and what role did he play….

One position, a million variables and we are picking from 4 different plates.

Brentford have set profiles agreed at all levels. They are ONLY interested in players who fit what they have all agreed is right for each position and need. Their strikers are good at x y z. They have wide forwards who are good at x y z. When they spend it is on players who look like x y z. When they sign short term it is on players who look like x y z to do a b c jobs.

Lose toney, your talismanic line stretching cf who is good with his feet and a physical battle to deal with? Sign Thiago. Lose mbuemo your left footed right winger* known for his blistering pace and threat when cutting inside? Sign Dango.

Then Brighton tbh are another level again, with players signing for them in this window you won’t see for another 2 years.

I’m sure there’s exceptions at these clubs and transfers that haven’t worked and Aaron hickey doesn’t look exactly like their other rb etc etc but the fact is…both of these clubs were mid table championship sides in the last 10-15 years.

They’ve implemented strategies and structures that go beyond manager, head coach, DOF, CEO, one window, two window. If their manager leaves they don’t go back to the drawing board and ask who are we, they say who suits who we are? If apple’s CEO leaves they don’t start selling garden tools.

Could you confidently say who we are? Could you confidently say who decides that? When was the last time we did know, and what happens in 6 months time when the manager is sacked, or in two weeks time when the ceo is sacked…who are we then?

It’s not enough to spend 40m on dibbling and have your manager treat him like an U21 graduate, he might bring your average age profile down but the plan isn’t joined together top to bottom and tbh most of the time doesn’t look like there is a plan beyond listen to whoever won this seasons boardroom battle.
Pretty aptly put about our shortcomings.

The difference between us and Bournemouth/Brentford/ Brighton is that they shook up their entire process of the functioning of the club which has led to their success as they could afford to do that shake up. Shaking up the entire process also ends up catastrophic in many cases like Watford, Blackburn, QPR etc.

We are pretty much a legacy mid table team who can't afford a major shake up in our functioning. We do that and if it goes wrong we end up in championship which will be a major loss for owners. No owner is going to approve a complete change of system with such a high risk of loss in revenues.You don't see a major shift in the way they have operated of any team who have been there in top flights for the last 10-15 seasons. Chelsea is the only exception who have been pretty much a yo-yo club post those changes. Other major teams haven't really changed their mantra for success.

We are like Skoda or any average car company compared to something like BYD or Tesla who can quick decisions because their entire success was based on risky and new technologies. Skoda and others can't change their directions that soon. It's the perils that comes with relative stability.

We should either reset the entire set up and risk going down or we should aim for a good 4-5 year set up of constant improvements to reach European football consistently while improving the team, scouting network and more importantly our finances. Currently we are just clueless with no clear plans. Heads need to roll after such a shambolic summer when everyone was quite sure what was needed for the past 4-5 months.
Locked Previous topicNext topic