Yeah, we are very very different.Matt1878 wrote: Wed Sep 02, 2026 5:07 pm Average age of squad
Brighton 24.6
Everton 25.3
Bournemouth 25.5
Brentford 25.8
https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/premier ... bewerb/GB1
I'd say we're trying to follow a similar model, our older players (Picks/Tarks/Keane) are just old because they have been around for ages. We do have a decent young talent pool in the team and we've sold our best player for a sizeable profit.
Is our model that different? Or are we just more innept at getting the deals done along with a complete disconnect with the manager's approach in terms of backing youth... as when we do sign them (Dibling, Aznou... possibly George now Grealish is back) they're not what he wants.
One random example - our options at ST on deadline day were
1. Keeping Beto
2. Signing Balogun
3. Loaning Zirkzee
4. Signing Tammy
One position, four very different options. Is he going to be a back up? Is he going to be the main man? Is he here for 6 months, is he here for 4 years, is he good in the air, good on the break, good with his feet but barely gets past a jog, does he score goals, what level has he scored goals, does he get assists, what kinds of teams has he played in and what role did he play….
One position, a million variables and we are picking from 4 different plates.
Brentford have set profiles agreed at all levels. They are ONLY interested in players who fit what they have all agreed is right for each position and need. Their strikers are good at x y z. They have wide forwards who are good at x y z. When they spend it is on players who look like x y z. When they sign short term it is on players who look like x y z to do a b c jobs.
Lose toney, your talismanic line stretching cf who is good with his feet and a physical battle to deal with? Sign Thiago. Lose mbuemo your left footed right winger* known for his blistering pace and threat when cutting inside? Sign Dango.
Then Brighton tbh are another level again, with players signing for them in this window you won’t see for another 2 years.
I’m sure there’s exceptions at these clubs and transfers that haven’t worked and Aaron hickey doesn’t look exactly like their other rb etc etc but the fact is…both of these clubs were mid table championship sides in the last 10-15 years.
They’ve implemented strategies and structures that go beyond manager, head coach, DOF, CEO, one window, two window. If their manager leaves they don’t go back to the drawing board and ask who are we, they say who suits who we are? If apple’s CEO leaves they don’t start selling garden tools.
Could you confidently say who we are? Could you confidently say who decides that? When was the last time we did know, and what happens in 6 months time when the manager is sacked, or in two weeks time when the ceo is sacked…who are we then?
It’s not enough to spend 40m on dibbling and have your manager treat him like an U21 graduate, he might bring your average age profile down but the plan isn’t joined together top to bottom and tbh most of the time doesn’t look like there is a plan beyond listen to whoever won this seasons boardroom battle.