AjaxAndy wrote: Wed Sep 02, 2026 8:49 am Multiple reasons.
Firstly we sold Ndaiye not to buy a striker but to comply with SCR, it's the only explanation as to why we accepted Forest's bid for Armstrong. Whilst spending £40m of £65m might seem a lot, the reality is with how deals are structured it'll have kept us compliant.
Secondly I think Moyes watched Barry miss 3 gilt edged chances at the weekend and wanted someone who was a reliable finisher.
Thirdly Beto was in the last year of his contract and we would have been pretty stupid to give him a new one, so selling while he still had value and replacing with a better and more reliable one was the right move.
Unfortunately on points 2 and 3 we didn't end up with anyone so the whole thing was a complete and utter fucking disaster.
On point 1, whilst we'll comply with CSR comfortably you'd imagine now we've not signed anyone, that was also an unmitigated disaster as we left it so late to accept we weren't getting £85m for Ndaiye from somewhere, that we tried to sell our prized academy graduate, then accepted shite terms from Spurs, before selling for what we could have got for Ndaiye earlier in the window, and left us more time to sort out the striker situation.
Absolutely farce by everyone involved.
1. We sold Ndiaye to comply with SCR
- very happy to accept we needed to sell in order to build out the squad. Is not necessarily what the club have been saying? But does seem to have been the case.
- Did we have to sell to *comply* with SCR? If so, where have you got this?
2. Moyes wanted another striker
- worrying if true. If it is the case that Barry came up against a goalie who made two really good stops after scoring 4in his first 2 games we would suddenly pivot to prioritise this position so much that we’re not getting cover, we’re not getting back up or competition…we’re paying top dollar for a peak aged striker on the last day, then Moyes wants legging with the rest of them.
3. Beto contract
- Good business to sell Beto for that fee. But same applies as (2). If we knew we were moving Beto on which we do all feel like was always on the cards…what was the plan until the pivot? Was it always to pay top dollar? Does anyone believe a top dollar centre forward does anything meaningful to our immediate or long term aims? What would Balogun have to achieved in order to make this desperate swing worthwhile…for me, CL. If anyone believes he was going to bag 30 goals and get us champions league they’re smoking fucking crack.
You can rationalise all you want.
We all know there was challenges going into the window and I think it’s fair to say are fairly sympathetic to them? None of us were saying get us champions league now. We knew there was work to be done.
all clubs have challenges btw, all clubs have aging players, injury hit players, squad cost challenges, these are not exceptional to Everton but the normal state of play for a football team. Look at villa and Newcastle as two not even particularly well run clubs. Look at palace a few years ago. Challenges do not excuse poor performance and rationalising in this way only supports the substandard running of the club.
I don’t even think the striker challenge will be THAT bad, will mostly be a hit to George who will have to play as a striker. No bigger hit than bringing in Jack to play ahead of him on the left though.
What I do think is bad is how clear the strategy has been exposed, how badly the football set up has been exposed, how disparate and desperate the player choices have been, and once again we’ve been shown up as being years behind even average ran club in this league.