Next Everton Manager

This is the new NSNO Everton forum to discuss the Mighty Blues

Who should be next Everton manager?

Jose Mourinho
4
7%
David Moyes
11
20%
Lee Carsley
7
13%
Thomas Frank
10
18%
Edin Terzic
2
4%
Steve Cooper
0
No votes
Leighton Baines
2
4%
David Wagner
0
No votes
Massimiliano Allegri
2
4%
Michael Carrick
2
4%
Danny Rohl
8
14%
Gareth Southgate
0
No votes
Dave From The Pub
4
7%
Other
4
7%
 
Total votes: 56

The Doc
Posts: 1362
Karma: 890

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Bluebridge wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 4:19 pm Is he now in the running for us?
I must admit I did just look up his record.
kramer
Posts: 1372
Karma: 1542

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Tempting a manager from another club midseason is messy, time-consuming work. The only way I can see it for us is if McKenna is our guy and we can torpedo Ipswich in the process.

Not into Lopetegui at all.

Too bad Lucien Favre is absolutely cooked.
The Doc
Posts: 1362
Karma: 890

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

kramer wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 4:28 pm Tempting a manager from another club midseason is messy, time-consuming work. The only way I can see it for us is if McKenna is our guy and we can torpedo Ipswich in the process.

Not into Lopetegui at all.

Too bad Lucien Favre is absolutely cooked.
You're good for a hipster name. What other options have we got?
kramer
Posts: 1372
Karma: 1542

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

The Doc wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 4:35 pm You're good for a hipster name. What other options have we got?
Sorry, I have nothing for you.

I have basically no time to follow football outside of Everton anymore, unfortunately.

I’m looking up FBRef pages every time we’re linked with a player, it’s all I’ve got now.
blueToffee
User avatar
Posts: 2597
Karma: 904

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

kramer wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 1:58 pm If limping to safety with Dyche felt like an option, it would be my top choice.

You have score goals to win games and you have to create chances to score goals. The lack of both chances and goals combined, with him citing it as a long-term problem, tells me we’re doomed if we persist with him.
Yeah, it's not good enough on the pitch. There is no way to really sugar coat it.

I don't mean to add to the endless cycle of is it Dyche or is it the squad but it just feels like we really need to address both aspects unless we want to be effectively flipping a coin to get relegated.

I'm not trying to be a Dyche apologist as clearly we've seen the games this season. However, putting aside the poor standard of football we're playing for a minute, I look at where we could've finished without the points deduction last season and I look at who sits around there now and it's Spurs and Man United. Above them teams who have invested and improved and I struggle to see anyone above who squad wise is truly worse than us, and likewise those who are below us are squad wise pretty poor. Right now we sit where we are in what is probably the right place for the management/player talent we have and the investment we've not made in recent years. We probably belong with the likes of Wolves who also have been cutting costs. You could maybe argue a little about Brentford and Bournemouth but overall we are where we are for reasons of management and the players at our disposal.

I'd not be super excited to see a January go by with just Dyche gone and no significant improvements have been made to the players available. Even just 1 or 2 could make a huge difference. I'd also say IF the choice was limping along Dyche until summer but we invest significantly now in players I'd go for the latter all day long despite the turgidness because better players will impact games in spite of tactics.
Evertonian in NC
User avatar
Posts: 1098
Karma: 489

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Just let Bainesy do it. We won't go down, and it would be nice to have a few months of not hating the manager. Start again this summer. All we can do.

Hiring Moyes or Mourinho just prolongs our sentence in Hell.
"The best you can hope for is to die in your sleep." - Kenny Rogers (plausible Evertonian)
kramer
Posts: 1372
Karma: 1542

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Any idea how Baines is doing at the youth level?

I think we’re a bit beyond the point where we just need to be organized. Dyche is excellent on that front. We need ideas about how to actually build an attack and create a chance on top of said organization which is a bit trickier.

I don’t think I’d trust Baines in charge given his limited experience, regardless of how he’s been with our youth team, for what we need. This job needs a steady hand.
Shogun
User avatar
Posts: 11437
Karma: 8487

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Bielsa fed up of Uruguay yet?
74Blue
Posts: 591
Karma: 346

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

One slight issue with Moyes is that he does not like working with a DOF. He would want to call all of the shots.
kramer
Posts: 1372
Karma: 1542

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

74Blue wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 5:36 pm One slight issue with Moyes is that he does not like working with a DOF. He would want to call all of the shots.
He should probably be moving into that sort of role himself at this stage of his career.

I think he’d be good at it, removes most of the day-to-day grind of man management and taking training.
MayorFarnham
User avatar
Posts: 781
Karma: 399

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Shearer at Newcastle, Brooking at West Ham Freedman at Palace; these just give it to (insert most popular player you can think of) shouts hardly ever work.
kramer
Posts: 1372
Karma: 1542

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Shogun wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 5:33 pm Bielsa fed up of Uruguay yet?
We looking for an interim U21 manager?
Trowel
User avatar
Posts: 2070
Karma: 2762

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Shogun wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 5:33 pm Bielsa fed up of Uruguay yet?
I've literally just been looking at this for left field candidates - largely a load of absolute basket cases to be fair

Image
74Blue
Posts: 591
Karma: 346

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

kramer wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 5:39 pm He should probably be moving into that sort of role himself at this stage of his career.

I think he’d be good at it, removes most of the day-to-day grind of man management and taking training.
That's actually not a bad shout tbf. Could he come in until the end of the season as manager, then move upstairs into a DOF role? He's certainly got an eye for a bargain or two and knows the club inside out. I reckon he'd be a pretty decent DOF tbh. It's whether he'd be able to completely hang up his boots and let the head coach get on with the day to day coaching or would he be too tempted to get his tracky bottoms on and meddle in training.
Bluebridge
Posts: 1607
Karma: 883

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

74Blue wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 5:45 pm That's actually not a bad shout tbf. Could he come in until the end of the season as manager, then move upstairs into a DOF role? He's certainly got an eye for a bargain or two and knows the club inside out. I reckon he'd be a pretty decent DOF tbh. It's whether he'd be able to completely hang up his boots and let the head coach get on with the day to day coaching or would he be too tempted to get his tracky bottoms on and meddle in training.
Exactly what I said last week, makes a lot of sense.
Locked Previous topicNext topic