The NSNO Everton Forums

Is losing Garner and Gueye at the same time a good idea?

I think Moyes would resign if we sold Garner

sam of the south wrote: ↑Fri Jun 26, 2026 11:13 am I think Moyes would resign if we sold Garner

Another reason to sell

Two birds one stone! Joking (sort of)

I doubt we'd sell Garner and don't think the club from a PR perspective would sell him to anyone but someone like United or Arsenal or Chelsea and the like. With Gueye going then it would leave us needing to replace a big part of the team which I have little faith in us achieving.

I don't think Garner is irreplaceable though and £80m from Forest/Newcastle where we can then pay the £25m for Hackney wouldn't be the worst thing.

At the same time, Garner continues playing the way he is then we'll get big bucks for him next season if we want to sell, so I guess it's no rush or anything and maybe better to keep.

It would be madness to turn down anything 50 million or over for garner he is a good prem midfielder but easily replaced imo that kind of money could be used to reshape the squad

Everton are leading the race among Premier League clubs to sign Villarreal and Senegal Midfielder Pape Gueye

(Source - @matte.moretto )

Brownie wrote: ↑Fri Jun 26, 2026 12:12 pm Everton are leading the race among Premier League clubs to sign Villarreal and Senegal Midfielder Pape Gueye

(Source - @matte.moretto )

Give him the same number as Gana so everyone can keep their named shirts

Brownie wrote: ↑Fri Jun 26, 2026 12:12 pm Everton are leading the race among Premier League clubs to sign Villarreal and Senegal Midfielder Pape Gueye

(Source - @matte.moretto )

Is that Idrissa's Dad?

Will be knocking on a bit.

Dm, 27, would cost an absolute packet (although probably less than we’d get for James Garner, bizarrely)

sam of the south wrote: ↑Fri Jun 26, 2026 1:06 pm Dm, 27, would cost an absolute packet (although probably less than we’d get for James Garner, bizarrely)

Not in response to your post specificaly but to those in general who reckon Garner is shit yet we can get millions more for him than we would have to pay for a far better player to replace him, how does that work ?

Escalator wrote: ↑Fri Jun 26, 2026 2:08 pm Not in response to your post specificaly but to those in general who reckon Garner is shit yet we can get millions more for him than we would have to pay for a far better player to replace him, how does that work ?

He’s definitely not shit, but he’s not elite, yet we could probably get top dollar for him as he’s had a really good season, has signed a new contract, he’s still a good age, and he’s an English premier league player.

Not the most reliable of sources, but for what it's worth

Shogun wrote: ↑Fri Jun 26, 2026 10:41 am Would be a great time to cash in on Garner tbf given the amount of money flying around this summer. £70-80m you'd imagine.

I don't think we'd sell to a Newcastle or Forest though.

Reckon we’d sell to anyone at the right price. We desperately need to rebuild.

Toddacelli wrote: ↑Fri Jun 26, 2026 5:35 pm Reckon we’d sell to anyone at the right price. We desperately need to rebuild.

I don’t think that now is the time to rebuild, as I don’t think Moyes is the man for that.

Toddacelli wrote: ↑Fri Jun 26, 2026 5:35 pm Reckon we’d sell to anyone at the right price. We desperately need to rebuild.

Not sure weve ever been open to selling first team players for the right price. We seem to always have to be forced into it