The NSNO Everton Forums

Silas wrote: ↑Tue Jul 08, 2025 12:30 pm 3 of them were basically shit

I hope Gibson is the exception! Decent player when fit

Silas wrote: ↑Tue Jul 08, 2025 12:32 pm James Mc Carthy, Tom Davies both the epitome of, "Do a job" players.

McCarthy was quality for a season. Tom Davies quite crap for me, though injuries didn't help.

There are some dubious calls here.

Some of them like Osman were pretty good players above a decent level

And then some of them, let’s be frank, were just plain rubbish

David Weir
Alan Stubbs
John Collins
Joe-Max Moore

Hibbert Andy Johnson and Oviedo

David weir not approved

Landon Donavon
James McFadden
Joel Robles
Theo Walcott

Li Tie - exceptional post football career though

Stuart Barlow

Pistone

James Tarkowski
Lucas Digne
Alex Iwobi
Gerard Deulofeu

Decent thread

All of them will get rejected by the Ram of God.

Digne absolutely not approved

Tarkowski not approved

Big Marco Materazzi

Wayne Clarke

I wonder how many on here are going “who?”

Paul Power
Matt Jackson
Alan Harper
Kevin Richardson