Decent Everton players

[Shogun]

3 of them were basically shit

I hope Gibson is the exception! Decent player when fit

James Mc Carthy, Tom Davies both the epitome of, "Do a job" players.

McCarthy was quality for a season. Tom Davies quite crap for me, though injuries didn't help.

[Gary1878]

There are some dubious calls here.

Some of them like Osman were pretty good players above a decent level

And then some of them, let’s be frank, were just plain rubbish

[blueforyou]

David Weir
Alan Stubbs
John Collins
Joe-Max Moore

[Kerryblueboy]

Hibbert Andy Johnson and Oviedo

[TheRam]

David weir not approved

[StirlingBlue]

Landon Donavon
James McFadden
Joel Robles
Theo Walcott

[StirlingBlue]

Li Tie - exceptional post football career though

[Escalator]

Stuart Barlow

[Birko Blue]

Pistone

[blueforyou]

James Tarkowski
Lucas Digne
Alex Iwobi
Gerard Deulofeu

Decent thread

[Shogun]

All of them will get rejected by the Ram of God.

[TheRam]

Digne absolutely not approved

Tarkowski not approved

[Cereal Killer]

Big Marco Materazzi

[Bluebridge]

Wayne Clarke

I wonder how many on here are going “who?”

[Mouse]

Paul Power
Matt Jackson
Alan Harper
Kevin Richardson