Best Everton PL English XI

[superpull]

Andy Johnson then

[TheRam]

Andy Johnson then

Over DCL?

[biziclop]

Andy Johnson then

Or if we're going with vibes of how good they could've been, like with Barkley, why not James Vaughan.

[velimski]

Beardsley gets in over DCL imo.

In fact, I'm not sure there's even a debate to be had.

[superpull]

Over DCL?

1 in 3.5 as opposed to DCLs 1 in 4 (1 in 3.8 for Campbell) and was rapid enough to ensure all teams had to play a deeper line than they'd have liked.


Also, @biziclop , can throw a Danny Cadamarteri onto the bench with Vaughan as well

[TheRam]

Pickford

Hibbert Stones Jags Baines

Barry Barkley

Watson Rooney Osman

Campbell

Struggled for wingers. Watson gets in as he had a good few years here and scored some belters.

Campbell gets in over DCL as he has a better scoring record in worse teams and scored better goals.

[TheRam]

Reckon you could make a good rest of the uk and Ireland team.

Southall
Coleman Gough Weir Naysmith

Speed Carsley

Naismith Huchtinson McFadden

Ferguson

[cassius]

I'd have Mick O'Lenko at left back instead of Naysmith.

[Goaljira]

Rest of the World XI
[3-4-1-2]
Howard
Materazzi
Distin
Ferrari
Pienaar
Arteta
Fellaini
Kanchelskis
Cahill
Yakubu
Lukaku

[Cozzie]

I reckon the Yak and Lukaku up front would have won us the quadruple.

Yakaku.

[Bluebridge]

Rest of the World XI
[3-4-1-2]
Howard
Materazzi
Distin
Ferrari
Pienaar
Arteta
Fellaini
Kanchelskis
Cahill
Yakubu
Lukaku

surely Yobo over Ferrari?

[Goaljira]

surely Yobo over Ferrari?

Yeah, definitely. I was really struggling for defenders. I nearly had to put Heitinga in there.

[blueforyou]

Pickford
Stones Jagielka Branthwaite
Snodin Parkinson Barry Baines
Barkley
Beardsley Rooney

Martyn; Lescott; Unsworth; D Watson; B Kenny; Osman; Barmby; Campbell; DCL

[blueforyou]

Howard
Yobo Bilic Distin
Kanchelskis Arteta Donovan Pienaar
Cahill
James Lukaku

[Cods]

We've had some good centre backs over the years.

Tarkowski Stones Jagielka Branthwaite Yobo Bilic Distin Lescott Gough Weir Lescott Unsworth Watson Materazzi Ferrari Stubbs...