Next Everton Manager

This is the new NSNO Everton forum to discuss the Mighty Blues

Who should be next Everton manager?

Jose Mourinho
4
7%
David Moyes
11
20%
Lee Carsley
7
13%
Thomas Frank
10
18%
Edin Terzic
2
4%
Steve Cooper
0
No votes
Leighton Baines
2
4%
David Wagner
0
No votes
Massimiliano Allegri
2
4%
Michael Carrick
2
4%
Danny Rohl
8
14%
Gareth Southgate
0
No votes
Dave From The Pub
4
7%
Other
4
7%
 
Total votes: 56

Escalator
Posts: 3127
Karma: 1035

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

74Blue wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 5:45 pm That's actually not a bad shout tbf. Could he come in until the end of the season as manager, then move upstairs into a DOF role? He's certainly got an eye for a bargain or two and knows the club inside out. I reckon he'd be a pretty decent DOF tbh. It's whether he'd be able to completely hang up his boots and let the head coach get on with the day to day coaching or would he be too tempted to get his tracky bottoms on and meddle in training.
So we would sack Thelwell for Moyes ?
74Blue
Posts: 591
Karma: 346

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Escalator wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 5:48 pm So we would sack Thelwell for Moyes ?
He's out of contract at the end of the season, so no sacking necessary.
TheRam
Posts: 6361
Karma: 6501

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Being a director of football involves more than just buying players though.
kramer
Posts: 1372
Karma: 1542

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

I know he’s got a good job already and that a lot of Brighton’s good decision-making starts with ownership but we should at least be sounding out David Weir for that role if we don’t continue with Thelwell.
Paddockoldie
Posts: 1425
Karma: 690

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

kramer wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 5:56 pm I know he’s got a good job already and that a lot of Brighton’s good decision-making starts with ownership but we should at least be sounding out David Weir for that role if we don’t continue with Thelwell.
I was talking to someone about Davie and he said he was approached a few years ago snd turned us down.
kramer
Posts: 1372
Karma: 1542

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

TheRam wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 5:53 pm Being a director of football involves more than just buying players though.
I think Moyes is generally excellent at all aspects of long-term football strategy. Probably his biggest strength, even more so than coaching, where he can be a bit too slow to react and too conservative tactically overall.

We weren’t just excellent in the market while he was here, we were also pretty outstanding on the sports science side of things. Then Martinez gutted the operation for his guys and we’ve haven’t been right since.

It’s kind of amazing how much he did while he was here. Also turned out to be our downfall when he walked, even though it had gone stale.
kramer
Posts: 1372
Karma: 1542

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Paddockoldie wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 5:58 pm I was talking to someone about Davie and he said he was approached a few years ago snd turned us down.
That tracks. You don’t leave a stable job at Brighton to work with someone like Moshiri.

Friedkin actually has money so different situation now.

Still a long shot but I think he needs to be reapproached given the new circumstances.
NickNack
Posts: 993
Karma: 560

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Bluebridge wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 5:47 pm Exactly what I said last week, makes a lot of sense.
I posted similar recently - could work, unless they’re already sorting a deal with Thelwell
Paddockoldie
Posts: 1425
Karma: 690

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

kramer wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 6:05 pm That tracks. You don’t leave a stable job at Brighton to work with someone like Moshiri.

Friedkin actually has money so different situation now.

Still a long shot but I think he needs to be reapproached given the new circumstances.
I'd look at their recruitment team too
Kerryblueboy
Posts: 2503
Karma: 689

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Some lads have very rose tinted opinions of moyes he was great here but how could you have him as dof he would totally undermine a new head coach
kramer
Posts: 1372
Karma: 1542

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Kerryblueboy wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 6:53 pm Some lads have very rose tinted opinions of moyes he was great here but how could you have him as dof he would totally undermine a new head coach
In a hypothetical world where he’s willing to move upstairs, he’d have to understand that it means giving up day-to-day control and focusing on long-term planning. Maybe he’s too much of a control freak to handle that, maybe not. Impossible to say.

He’s earned the rose tinted opinions for me. Not one single manager has properly looked after the long-term well-being of the club since. I think he’d do well given time to simply focus on planning and transfer strategy but it’s just a guess.
Silas
User avatar
Posts: 1369
Karma: 916

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Mourinho might want to prove he can do something with a team in the shit, he would enjoy a club like Everton I think. Would be a huge risk but would definitely be interesting
Evertonian418
Posts: 675
Karma: 176

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

I liked Moyes in his time but we have to move forward.
sam of the south
Posts: 1930
Karma: 1490

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Yay, the yesterday’s men thread
kramer
Posts: 1372
Karma: 1542

Re: Next Everton Manager

Post

Silas wrote: Wed Jan 08, 2025 7:05 pm Mourinho might want to prove he can do something with a team in the shit, he would enjoy a club like Everton I think. Would be a huge risk but would definitely be interesting
In theory.

I wonder how much sticking it to Barca / Guardiola fueled him.

Had one great season winning the PL with Chelsea but otherwise hasn’t been the same manager since his Real stint. He got his revenge, won basically everyhting he could win. What’s left?
Locked Previous topicNext topic