There's just too many questions because the process wasn't really thought out to ever be punished in reality, but then they've panicked about the prospect of independant regulation putting a stop to their shady goings on and gone all in without really having a plan other than making us the sacrificial lamb.Shogun wrote: ↑Fri Feb 23, 2024 1:08 pm Yeah, Goaljira is spot on. A bit like the PGMOL, it's difficult to know if it's arrogance or incompetence when it comes to Everton.
The only thing I can't take about the two punishments is that they're going to be applied in the same season. It can't be right that you're punished twice in the same season for going over the threshold in two different accounting periods.
I get that we'd have been relegated had it been applied last season but it's not our fault that the Premier League is incompetent and have allowed it go over this long. Whatever the second charge, it should be being applied for next season.
- How does the second penalty work if we go down anyway - does it hold over to if/when we come back up and we start on -10 then?
- If we go down it'd take a miracle for us not to fall foul of the stricter EFL limits for the period after, so when would that apply to the following season or if we come back up when/if we go back down?
- Whats the statute of limitations on a points deduction? How does that change when the rules change in August - we start the season with a deduction based on failure to comply with a different set of rules?
- How does this apply to the likes of City and Chelsea if they're ever even brought to a hearing? If they're offences were over different time periods, are they only allowed to be penalised for one period per season?
My main concern now is that the reason for the deduction is made clear, so that everyone knows where they stand. So that we know what punishment can be expected for the second charge, and for Forest's charge, and that City and Chelsea will be dealt with in the same harsh terms. But the rule change in the summer completely fucks things in that realistically other than next season no one is likely to come close to being charged under the current rules and everyone is running scared this year because of whats happened to us so there likely won't be any failures. Well, you know, unless we manage to survice irrespective and we've still completely fucked things up with our dodgy loans.